Toby Calloway

Toby Calloway, age 53, passed away on Monday, April 27, 2026, at his home in Galloway, Ohio, after several years of declining health. Toby was born on January 5, 1973, in Columbus, Ohio, to the late Richard Calloway and Debbie Lillie. He was a graduate of West Jefferson High School, Class of 1991, where he loved playing basketball. He worked as a production manager at Tarrier Foods until he retired due to his health. He enjoyed NASCAR, The Ohio State Buckeyes, fishing, and demolition derby.

Toby was preceded in death by his father Richard Calloway, grandparents Jim and Jeannie Ball, and Paul and Peggy Calloway, and his uncles Doug Ball, and Paul Calloway, and aunt Donna Calloway.

Toby is survived by his son Justin Finley, sister Abbey Lillie, parents Debbie and Doug Lillie, aunts and uncles Tim and Connie Ball, Jim Ball, and Emmet Calloway, many cousins, and special friend Debbie Lombardo.

In accordance with the family's wishes, cremation will take place, and no formal services will be held at this time.